4.04. Witness Wilfully False | Pdf Doc Docx | Illinois_JI

 Illinois Jury Instructions   Civil   004 Instructions Recommended Not To Be Given 
4.04. Witness Wilfully False | Pdf Doc Docx | Illinois_JI

Last updated: 12/30/2011

4.04. Witness Wilfully False

Start Your Free Trial $ 13.99
200 Ratings
What you get:
  • Instant access to fillable Microsoft Word or PDF forms.
  • Minimize the risk of using outdated forms and eliminate rejected fillings.
  • Largest forms database in the USA with more than 80,000 federal, state and agency forms.
  • Download, edit, auto-fill multiple forms at once in MS Word using our Forms Workflow Ribbon
  • Trusted by 1,000s of Attorneys and Legal Professionals


4.04 Witness Willfully False The committee recommends that no instruction on the willfully false witness be given. Comment This instruction was formerly IPI 2.04. Instructions have been given which inform jurors that the testimony of a witness who has knowingly and willfully sworn falsely on a material issue may be disregarded, unless it has been corroborated by other credible evidence. It was required that it be accompanied by an appropriate instruction defining matter material to the issue. McManaman v. Johns-Manville Prods. Corp., 400 Ill. 423, 81 N.E.2d 137 (1948); Schneiderman v. Interstate Transit Lines, 401 Ill. 172, 81 N.E.2d 861 (1948); McQuillen v. Evans, 353 Ill. 239, 187 N.E. 320 (1933). It is recommended that an instruction of this type not be given. It is argumentative, invades the province of the jury, and suggests the court's belief that a witness has sworn falsely. It emphasizes the issue of false testimony which is a matter solely within the province of the jury. Again, determination of a witness' credibility is the subject of standards outlined in IPI 1.01[4] on credibility of witnesses. The matter of testimony which is knowingly or willfully false is not to be confused with impeachment by prior inconsistent or contradictory statements, which is adequately covered by IPI 1.01[4].

Related forms

Our Products